---
title: "What is the GHG Protocol?\nHow does it differ from Bilan Carbone®?"
description: "GHG Protocol explained: 3 Scopes, 15 categories, 7 gases and the overhaul with ISO. How it differs from Bilan Carbone® and which standard to use."
canonical: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-vs-ghg-protocol/
author: "Alexandre Veilly"
datePublished: 2026-04-12
dateModified: 2026-10-17
language: en
translationOf: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/ghg-protocol-vs-bilan-carbone-methode/
---

# What is the GHG Protocol? How does it differ from Bilan Carbone®?

**Author**: Alexandre Veilly
**Published**: 2026-04-12
**Updated**: 2026-10-17
**Section**: Explained
**Canonical URL**: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-vs-ghg-protocol/
**French original**: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/ghg-protocol-vs-bilan-carbone-methode/
**Source**: Projet Celsius (https://projetcelsius.com/en/), a climate strategy consultancy of engineers and PhDs based in Paris and Marseille.

> The GHG Protocol is the **international carbon accounting standard** for companies, published since 2001 by the WRI and the WBCSD. It sorts emissions into **3 Scopes**, including a Scope 3 with 15 categories, and counts 7 gases. Bilan Carbone® (the French carbon accounting method) counts the same emissions in 10 categories; a correspondence table from the Association pour la transition Bas Carbone (ABC), the French low-carbon transition association, which maintains the method, links them **source by source**. The 2 methods are compatible with ISO 14064-1, and ISO and the GHG Protocol are preparing a single standard.

## Key takeaways

- **The GHG Protocol** has been the global carbon accounting standard since 2001.
- **3 Scopes, 15 categories and 7 gases** make up its accounting grid.
- **Bilan Carbone®**, the French method, counts the same emissions in 10 categories.
- The format depends on **who receives the footprint**: the BEGES, the CSRD, SBTi or investors.

The GHG Protocol, short for Greenhouse Gas Protocol, is the **international carbon accounting standard** for companies. It has been published since 2001 by the World Resources Institute (WRI) and the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD). In 2023, **97% of the S&P 500 companies** that responded to the CDP (the environmental disclosure platform) reported their emissions using it, according to the [GHG Protocol](https://ghgprotocol.org/about-us).

In France, it coexists with a method that emerged at almost the same time, the [Bilan Carbone® method](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-method-explained/) (the French carbon accounting method). The 2 count the same emissions and organise them differently. Which one to choose depends mainly on **what the footprint is used for** and who will read it.

## What is the GHG Protocol?

The GHG Protocol emerged in the late 1990s from a **partnership** between a non-governmental organisation, the WRI, and a network of companies, the WBCSD. Its standards are **free to download** and are revised by an **independent standards board**, supported by technical working groups. In 2007, ISO summed up how the two share the ground: the ISO 14064 standard, published in 2006, sets out what must be done to account for emissions, and the GHG Protocol also sets out **how to do it**.

### A family of standards

The GHG Protocol is a suite of standards, published and extended since 2001. For a company's carbon footprint, 4 documents and 1 amendment matter:

- The **Corporate Standard**, published in 2001 and revised in 2004, sets out the principles, the boundary and the 3 Scopes. It is the foundation for all the others ([GHG Protocol](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/standards/ghg-protocol-revised.pdf)).
- The 2011 **Scope 3 Standard** splits value chain emissions into **15 categories**, detailed in our [Scope 3 guide](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/scope-3-emissions-guide/) ([GHG Protocol](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/standards/Corporate-Value-Chain-Accounting-Reporing-Standard_041613_2.pdf)).
- The **Product Standard**, published the same year, applies to the footprint of a product, an approach close to [life cycle assessment](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/lca-vs-carbon-footprint/).
- The **February 2013 amendment** adds nitrogen trifluoride to the 6 gases of the Kyoto Protocol: an inventory has counted **7 gases** since then ([GHG Protocol](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/2022-12/Required%20gases%20and%20GWP%20values_0.pdf)).
- The 2015 **Scope 2 Guidance** requires 2 calculations for purchased electricity, one based on the grid and the other based on contracts.

The Corporate Standard sets out **5 principles**: relevance, completeness, consistency, transparency and accuracy. It requires **Scopes 1 and 2 at a minimum** and leaves Scope 3 optional, even though the standards of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and of the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) now call for it.

### An overhaul under way with ISO

The GHG Protocol is **undergoing a thorough revision**. Its consultation on Scope 2, held from 20 October to 19 December 2025, received **nearly 1,100 responses** from 56 countries. On 9 September 2025, [ISO and the GHG Protocol](https://www.iso.org/news/2025/09/iso-and-ghgp-partnership) announced that they would **merge their standards**. On 29 July 2026, the GHG Protocol set out the timetable: a **single standard**, carrying the 2 logos, will go to public consultation in the second quarter of 2027 ([GHG Protocol](https://ghgprotocol.org/blog/ghg-protocol-announces-key-standard-development-updates)).

## How does the GHG Protocol sort emissions?

Before counting, the company sets its **organisational boundary**. The Corporate Standard gives it **2 approaches**: the share of equity it holds in each entity, or control, financial or operational. The emissions within that boundary are then sorted into 3 Scopes:

- **Scope 1** covers direct emissions from sources that the company owns or controls: boilers, furnaces, vehicles, processes, refrigerant leaks.
- **Scope 2** covers purchased electricity, steam, heat and cooling. Since 2015 it has been reported **in 2 ways**: using the average grid mix and using purchase contracts, guarantees of origin included.
- **Scope 3** covers all other indirect emissions, from the extraction of purchased materials to the end of life of products sold, in 15 categories: **8 upstream and 7 downstream**.

CO2 from the combustion of biomass is **reported separately**, outside Scope 1. The Scopes are defined so that **2 companies never count the same emission in the same Scope**: a carrier's Scope 1 becomes its customer's Scope 3. This grid, shared by large groups worldwide, is what makes the GHG Protocol the **language of buyers** when they [check their suppliers' data](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/verify-supplier-emissions-data/).

## How does it differ from Bilan Carbone®?

Bilan Carbone® was created in 2004 by ADEME (the French Agency for Ecological Transition) and has been run since 2011 by the Association pour la transition Bas Carbone (ABC). Its methodological guide is now at version 9, published in July 2024, which the ABC calls the **Bilan Carbone® 2025 method**. It has 7 steps and **3 maturity levels**, Initial, Standard and Advanced, and adds a [transition plan](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/climate-transition-plan-requirements/) to the counting. According to the ABC, the method is **compatible with the GHG Protocol**, the regulatory method for France's mandatory greenhouse gas emissions report (BEGES), ISO 14064-1 and the CSRD.

### 2 ways of sorting the same emissions

Bilan Carbone® splits emissions into **10 emission categories and 48 subcategories**, by main flows: energy, inputs, freight, travel, capital goods, waste, end of life. The GHG Protocol sorts them by Scope, according to who controls the source. The [ABC method](https://www.bilancarbone-methode.com/4-comptabilisation/4.5-profil-demission) publishes a **correspondence table** between the 2, and its tools export the result in GHG Protocol format. The graphic below shows where each category lands.

### What the conversion moves

The mapping works **source by source**, not category by category. The Bilan Carbone® "energy" category also counts fuel upstream emissions and transmission and distribution losses, which the GHG Protocol places in **Scope 3, category 3**. Freight and travel fall under **Scope 1 when the company operates the vehicles**, and under Scope 3 otherwise. Visitor travel and product use "under dependency" have **no category at all** in the GHG Protocol.

For the export to work, each source must therefore be **characterised at the data collection stage**: operated or not, owned or leased, paid for by the company or not. This characterisation follows the control approach chosen. A well-built footprint **converts without recollecting data**. A footprint entered category by category forces you to go back to the teams for this information.

> Moving from Bilan Carbone® to the GHG Protocol requires knowing, for each source, who controls it and who pays for it.

### Governance and emission factors

The ABC maintains the method, trains practitioners and, since 2025, offers an **evaluation of footprints** by certified experts, together with AFNOR Certification (part of AFNOR, the French standards body) and the French Order of Chartered Accountants. The GHG Protocol publishes standards **without certifying those who apply them**. Nor does it set any rule on how a verification should be carried out, as our guide to [having an in-house footprint verified](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/in-house-carbon-footprint-third-party-verification/) points out. On emission factors, Bilan Carbone® uses **Base Empreinte**, ADEME's public emission factor database, as its reference in France; the GHG Protocol leaves the choice of sources open, provided they are documented.

## What role does ISO 14064 play?

[ISO 14064-1](https://www.iso.org/fr/standard/66453.html), in its 2018 version, is the international standard for quantifying an organisation's emissions. It sorts emissions into **6 categories**, a grid used by the regulatory method of the [BEGES](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/beges-france-mandatory-ghg-report/): according to the ADEME platform, a regulatory BEGES complies with this standard. The GHG Protocol, published before it, and Bilan Carbone® are **compatible with this standard** and with each other. The timeline below follows them on 2 lanes, the GHG Protocol on one side, ISO and France on the other, up to the proposed single standard.

ISO 14064-3 governs the **third-party verification** of an emissions statement. It **does not replace the calculation method**: it comes on top of it, when a customer, an investor or a framework such as SBTi asks for a verified footprint. The guide to the [verification of an existing footprint](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/in-house-carbon-footprint-third-party-verification/) covers this case, and the 2025 partnership between ISO and the GHG Protocol should in the long run bring the 2 grids together in a single standard.

## Which standard to choose depending on how the footprint is used?

The choice depends less on the method than on **who receives the footprint**. **Each framework cites its own standard**, and the graphic below summarises what the texts in force or published in October 2026 say.

For a French company, **a single data collection can serve the 2 formats**. Bilan Carbone® meets the BEGES and the [Diag Décarbon'Action](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/diag-decarbonaction-complete-guide/) (a carbon footprint programme subsidised by Bpifrance, the French public investment bank, for companies established in France); the GHG Protocol meets a sustainability statement (the CSRD sustainability report), an [SBTi pathway](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/sbti-for-industrial-smes/) or an international customer. The [revised CSRD standards](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/revised-esrs-2026/), the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), refer to the **Corporate Standard** while accepting ISO 14064-1, which the [climate standard ESRS E1](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/esrs-e1-ghg-inventory-after-omnibus/) spells out Scope by Scope. An SME outside this scope can still receive a request from a customer subject to the CSRD, a case covered in the [CSRD guide for SMEs](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/csrd-2026-who-is-in-scope-after-omnibus/).

**The choice of method does not change the price of a footprint.** The GHG Protocol and Bilan Carbone® require the same data collection and can use the same emission factors. Only the reporting format differs. When 2 quotes diverge, the gap comes from the size and number of sites of the company, the depth of Scope 3, handled through spend or through physical quantities, and the deliverables, transition plan included. The guide to the [price of a carbon footprint](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-cost-france/) gives orders of magnitude and a way to compare quotes. The choice of [carbon accounting software](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/carbon-accounting-software-vs-consultancy/) matters more, because it determines how each source will be characterised.

For us at Projet Celsius, the first question to ask at the scoping stage is "**who is this footprint for?**". We **characterise each source at the data collection stage**, operated or not, owned or leased, so that the same calculation comes out in the 2 formats. And we **follow the overhaul** of the GHG Protocol with ISO: the single standard expected after 2027 could change how Scope 2 is reported.

## Key takeaways

- The GHG Protocol is the **international standard** for carbon accounting, published by the WRI and the WBCSD since 2001 and used in 2023 by 97% of the S&P 500 companies that responded to the CDP.
- It sorts emissions into **3 Scopes** and Scope 3 into 15 categories; it counts 7 gases and reports Scope 2 in 2 ways.
- Bilan Carbone® sorts the same emissions into **10 categories**; an ABC table gives the correspondence, source by source.
- ISO 14064-1 is the international quantification standard, compatible with the 2 methods, and ISO 14064-3 governs verification.
- The choice follows **who receives the footprint**: the BEGES and the Diag programme on one side, the CSRD, SBTi and investors on the other.

The 7 steps and 3 levels of the French approach are covered in the [guide to the Bilan Carbone® method](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-method-explained/).

To see where your company stands on the BEGES, the ["Are you covered?" tool](https://projetcelsius.com/en/tools/beges-requirement-checker/) answers in 4 questions.

## Frequently asked questions

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the GHG Protocol?

It is the international greenhouse gas accounting standard, published since 2001 by the World Resources Institute and the World Business Council for Sustainable Development. Its Corporate Standard sets the boundary and the 3 Scopes; other standards cover Scope 2, Scope 3 and products.

### What is the difference between the GHG Protocol and Bilan Carbone®?

The 2 count the same emissions but sort them differently: 3 Scopes and 15 Scope 3 categories for the GHG Protocol, 10 emission categories and 48 subcategories for Bilan Carbone®. Bilan Carbone® adds a transition plan and an evaluation of footprints by the ABC. A correspondence table makes it possible to move from one to the other.

### Is the GHG Protocol mandatory in France?

No French law requires it as such. The BEGES is submitted in the format of the regulatory method, but the calculation can come from the GHG Protocol, from Bilan Carbone® or from another method that complies with ISO 14064-1. The revised ESRS of the CSRD refer to its Corporate Standard while accepting ISO 14064-1, and SBTi requires an inventory aligned with the GHG Protocol standards.

### How many gases does the GHG Protocol count?

7: the 6 gases of the Kyoto Protocol, namely CO2, methane, nitrous oxide, HFCs, PFCs and sulphur hexafluoride, plus nitrogen trifluoride, added by a February 2013 amendment. All are converted into CO2 equivalent using their global warming potential.

### Which ISO standard corresponds to the GHG Protocol?

ISO 14064-1, the standard for quantifying an organisation's emissions, in its current version published in 2018. According to ISO, the 2 have been compatible since the first version of the standard, in 2006. ISO and the GHG Protocol signed a partnership in September 2025, then announced in July 2026 a single standard, to go to consultation in the second quarter of 2027.

### Can you convert a Bilan Carbone® into GHG Protocol format?

Yes. The ABC method publishes a correspondence table and its tools export the result in GHG Protocol format. The conversion works source by source: for each emission, you need to know whether the company operates the vehicle or equipment, whether it owns it and whether it pays for the transport.

## Sources

**Sources**: [GHG Protocol, About Us, accessed on 17 October 2026](https://ghgprotocol.org/about-us); [WRI and WBCSD, GHG Protocol Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard, revised edition, 2004](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/standards/ghg-protocol-revised.pdf); [GHG Protocol, Required Greenhouse Gases in Inventories, February 2013 amendment](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/2022-12/Required%20gases%20and%20GWP%20values_0.pdf); [WRI and WBCSD, Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard, 2011](https://ghgprotocol.org/sites/default/files/standards/Corporate-Value-Chain-Accounting-Reporing-Standard_041613_2.pdf); [GHG Protocol, opening of the public consultations on Scope 2, 20 October 2025](https://ghgprotocol.org/blog/release-ghg-protocol-opens-public-consultations-scope-2-and-electricity-sector-consequential); [GHG Protocol, Key Standard Development Updates, 29 July 2026](https://ghgprotocol.org/blog/ghg-protocol-announces-key-standard-development-updates); [ISO, partnership with the GHG Protocol, 9 September 2025](https://www.iso.org/news/2025/09/iso-and-ghgp-partnership); [ISO, cooperation with the WRI and the WBCSD, December 2007](https://www.iso.org/news/2007/12/Ref1093.html); [ISO 14064-1:2018](https://www.iso.org/fr/standard/66453.html); [ABC, Bilan Carbone® 2025 method, section 4.5 "Emission profile"](https://www.bilancarbone-methode.com/4-comptabilisation/4.5-profil-demission) and [section 6.2 "Compatibility"](https://www.bilancarbone-methode.com/6-synthese-et-restitution/6.2-compatibilite-de-la-demarche-avec-dautres-referentiels) (both pages in French); [European Commission, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1563, revised ESRS, standard E1](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2026/1563/oj); [SBTi, Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0, June 2026](https://files.sciencebasedtargets.org/production/files/Corporate-Net-Zero-Standard-version-2.pdf). Cover photo: bus at the Perrache depot, Lyon, March 2026, Chabe01, [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bus_TCL_D%C3%A9p%C3%B4t_Perrache_Rue_Bichat_-_Lyon_II_%28FR69%29_-_2026-03-07_-_5.jpg), CC BY-SA 4.0.
