---
title: "How do you substantiate an environmental claim?\nWhat evidence does each claim need?"
description: "How to substantiate an environmental claim: the document for recycled, recyclable, compostable, carbon and label claims, who issues it, and printed stock."
canonical: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/green-claims-what-empco-bans/
author: "Sébastien Pierfederici"
datePublished: 2026-06-13
dateModified: 2026-10-31
language: en
translationOf: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/green-claims-prouver-allegation/
---

# How do you substantiate an environmental claim? What evidence does each claim need?

**Author**: Sébastien Pierfederici
**Published**: 2026-06-13
**Updated**: 2026-10-31
**Section**: Practical guide
**Canonical URL**: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/green-claims-what-empco-bans/
**French original**: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/green-claims-prouver-allegation/
**Source**: Projet Celsius (https://projetcelsius.com/en/), a climate strategy consultancy of engineers and PhDs based in Paris and Marseille.

> An environmental claim is substantiated by a document that says exactly what the sentence says, about the same product, and that exists **before publication**: a recycled content certificate for "recycled", a **life cycle assessment** for a carbon figure, an **official ecolabel** for a general term, a type of wording that France already prohibits on packaging. The French Consumer Code penalises misleading claims, and the [EmpCo Directive](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/what-is-empco-directive/) (Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition) tightens the rules. Here is the document to gather for each claim, then what to do with **packaging already printed**.

## Key takeaways

- **Evidence must exist before publication**, and cover the same object as the claim.
- **"Recycled" requires a percentage**, substantiated by a recycled content certificate.
- **A carbon figure is substantiated by a life cycle assessment**, with its method and scope.
- **Packaging already printed is sorted claim by claim**, without destroying the stock.

An environmental claim is substantiated by a document that says the same thing as the sentence, about the same object, and that exists **before publication**. "Contains 30% recycled plastic" is substantiated by the supplier's **recycled content certificate**, and a carbon figure by a **life cycle assessment (LCA)** that sets out its scope. A general term such as "ecological" cannot be substantiated by any measurement: on a product or packaging, it is even **already banned in France**.

The French Consumer Code penalises an environmental claim that is false or likely to mislead, and the 2005 European directive allows a court to require the trader to provide **proof that its claims are accurate**. The [EmpCo Directive](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/what-is-empco-directive/) has applied since **27 September 2026** in the Member States that have transposed it, according to [its timetable](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-application-dates/). In France, [the bill transposing it](https://www.senat.fr/dossier-legislatif/pjl25-118.html), adopted by the Senate on 18 February 2026, is still awaiting the National Assembly. The proposed Green Claims Directive, which would have required third-party verification before publication, appears in the Commission's [2027 work programme](https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/strategy-documents/commission-work-programme/commission-work-programme-2027_en) among the texts to be withdrawn within 6 months, as recalled in [the framework for environmental communication in 2026](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-directive-green-claims-guide/).

## What has to be substantiated, and when?

Everything that suggests an environmental benefit must be capable of being substantiated: **the text, but also the logo**, the colour or the name of the range. The [practical guide of the French National Consumer Council](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/les-fiches-pratiques/allegations-environnementales-ce-quil-faut-retenir) (CNC), published in 2023, draws 2 requirements from this. The evidence is available **as soon as the claim is used**, and it covers **what the sentence asserts**, neither wider nor narrower.

> **What is an environmental claim?** Under the EmpCo Directive, it is any non-mandatory message that states or suggests that a product or a business has a positive or zero impact on the environment, is less harmful than others, or has improved. It may take any form: text, image, symbol, label, brand or product name.

### Evidence ready before publication

The CNC guide asks traders to hold the evidence needed to support their claims from the moment the claims are used, or to be able to produce it on request. For a figure, the advertiser must give **the origin of the results** and **the calculation method**. A **supplier brochure** or an **expired certificate** does not count as evidence, as shown by the refusals published by the DGCCRF (the French consumer protection authority), which [our 3-question test](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/greenwashing-test-3-questions/) sets out.

### Evidence on the same object as the sentence

The evidence covers **exactly the scope asserted**. "Recyclable bottle" is substantiated on **the bottle as it is thrown away**, with its cap and label, and not on the resin of the body alone. A company-level claim ("we are reducing our emissions") calls for a company-wide [Bilan Carbone®](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bilan-carbone-method-explained/) (the French carbon accounting method), and a product claim for **a study of the product**. For a claim such as "eco-designed", the guide asks for it to specify whether it refers to the product or to the packaging: without that, it is read as covering the 2.

EmpCo also prohibits presenting a claim that concerns only **one aspect or one activity** as applying to the whole product or the whole business. Since 12 August 2026, the [European Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32025R0040), known as PPWR, also requires a claim about packaging to specify whether it refers to **the unit, a part of the packaging** or all of the company's packaging.

## What evidence for material and end-of-life claims?

Claims about material and end of life are the most common on packaging, and **the most tightly regulated in France**. For each one, the document that substantiates it is known in advance. The table below gives that document, who issues it and the point where it fails.

### "Recycled": a percentage and its traceability

Since 1 January 2022, a product or packaging described as recycled must state **the percentage of recycled material** effectively incorporated ([French Environmental Code, Article L. 541-9-1](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000041555718)). The evidence is **a certificate from the material supplier**, tied to the batch or the production period. It rests on a traceability method: standard **EN 15343** for recycled plastics, on which third-party certifications such as RecyClass are based. A percentage announced "on average over the year" is substantiated **over the year**, not on a single batch.

On packaging, the European regulation admits a claim about a property that it regulates, such as recycled content, only if the claim **goes beyond its minimum requirements**. The [recycled content of plastic packaging](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/ppwr-recycled-content-verification/) is therefore prepared together with the technical documentation required by the regulation, which also sets [minimum recycled plastic content](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/ppwr-recycled-plastic-content-targets/).

### "Recyclable": a recycling stream that exists in practice

A recyclability claim says that a stream **collects, sorts and recycles** the object in practice. The Environmental Code sets 5 criteria: the object is collected close to where people live, it is sorted, it contains no element that hinders sorting or recycling, and it is recycled at industrial scale. The recycled material obtained must also exceed **50% of the waste collected**. These criteria open the way to the claim "mostly recyclable", and to "fully recyclable" **above 95%**.

Companies with a turnover of more than €10 million that sell at least 10,000 units a year publish online a **product sheet** on these environmental qualities, which serves as the supporting document. For packaging, the producer responsibility organisation (PRO, éco-organisme in French) passes this recyclability information to the producer (Article R. 541-228). The exact vocabulary and its thresholds are set out in [the list of prohibited claims](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/banned-environmental-claims-eu/).

### "Compostable" and "biobased": a standard and a laboratory

A plastic that is compostable **only in an industrial facility** may not carry the claim "compostable", and any compostable plastic carries a notice not to discard it in the environment (Article L. 541-9-1). The evidence is **a test certificate on the whole product**, and not only on the polymer. Standard NF T51-800 covers home composting of a plastic, and standard EN 13432 industrial composting of packaging.

"Biobased" is substantiated by **a measurement of the biobased content**: radiocarbon analysis under standard NF EN 16640 or NF EN 16785-1, or material balance under NF EN 16785-2. The CNC guide asks for this content to be **displayed** when the product is only partly biobased. It points out that a biobased product is **not necessarily compostable**, recyclable or lower-impact.

## What evidence for a carbon figure or a label?

Claims about climate, comparisons and labels require **the heaviest evidence**, because they speak for the whole product or the whole company. Some have **no sufficient evidence at all**.

### An impact figure: a study that sets out its scope

"1.2 kgCO2e per unit" or "20% fewer emissions" are substantiated by a [life cycle assessment](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/product-carbon-footprint-lca-pef-cfp/) under the **ISO 14040 and 14044** standards. When the figure concerns climate only, a product carbon footprint under **ISO 14067** is enough. The study must say **what it covers**: cradle to factory gate or through to end of life, with which data. [Third-party verification of the footprint](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/product-carbon-footprint-verification/) strengthens the file, without being required.

For a streamlined LCA, the order of magnitude observed in 2026 is **€5,000 to €10,000 excl. VAT**, with no official price list, as our article on [the price of an LCA](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/lca-cost/) sets out. A study used only to substantiate a claim is scoped to **that scope alone**, which makes it possible to [carry out an LCA on a small budget](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/lca-on-a-small-budget/).

### A comparison: the same method on the 2 sides

"Less polluting" or "30% less plastic" compare against **a reference that must be named**: the former product, the market average or a competitor. The comparison is made on **the same unit and the same method** on the 2 sides. When an LCA underpins a **comparative assertion disclosed to the public**, ISO 14044 requires a critical review by a panel of interested parties. The choice [between a panel and a single expert](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/comparative-lca-review-panel-or-expert/) and what the reviewer checks are set out in [the article on comparative claims](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/comparative-environmental-claim-less-polluting/).

### A label or a general term: a third party, or nothing

EmpCo prohibits a sustainability label that rests **neither on a certification scheme** run by a third party nor on a public authority. A general term such as "ecological" is permitted only if the trader can demonstrate **recognised excellent environmental performance**: that of the [EU Ecolabel](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02010R0066-20171114) or of an official type I ecolabel. In France, the CNC guide already treats "ecological", "eco-responsible" and "green" as equivalents of "environmentally friendly", which is **prohibited on a product or packaging**.

2 cases have **no sufficient evidence** under EmpCo: the [neutrality of a product](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/carbon-neutral-claim-on-packaging/) **based on offsetting**, and an announced future performance without a detailed plan verified by an independent expert third party. In France, a "carbon neutral" claim remains governed by [Article L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000043960256), which requires the emissions assessment, the reduction pathway and the offsetting to be published, as [the article on carbon neutrality](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/carbon-neutral-claims-what-companies-can-say/) explains.

> No measurement substantiates a general term such as "ecological", and French law already prohibits it on a product or its packaging.

## What does a solid evidence file contain?

The file is built **claim by claim**, not product by product: a claim repeated across a whole range **needs substantiating only once**, provided the document covers each product reference. For each claim, a sheet brings together **6 fields** that the company must be able to produce on request. They are the wording and where it appears, the scope, the method, the result and its data, the documents signed by third parties, and the review date. The example below fills in one.

A document in good order is not enough **when it says less than the sentence**. Packaging that announces "100% recycled" when the supplier certifies 87%, for example, does not hold up, even with a valid certificate. The document must also **cover what is sold**: the DGCCRF found a furniture store announcing that "the majority of the wood" was FSC certified, when the certification concerned only a minority of products. And evidence **ages**, since each certificate has a validity date. For packaging, these documents join the [technical documentation under the European regulation](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/ppwr-technical-documentation-supplier-evidence/), kept for **5 years** for single-use packaging and **10 years** for reusable packaging.

## How do you reword a claim you cannot substantiate?

A claim without evidence is reworded to **say what the document proves**, or it is withdrawn. The 4 most common cases are handled as follows, the figures being examples:

- "Ecological packaging" becomes "packaging containing at least 80% recycled material", the wording used in the Environmental Code, backed by the cardboard supplier's certificate.
- "Low-carbon product" becomes "1.2 kgCO2e per unit, cradle to factory gate, according to an ISO 14044 LCA", with the study in the file.
- "Natural formula", on a cosmetic, becomes "92% ingredients of natural origin according to ISO 16128", with the line-by-line calculation of the formula that [the cosmetics eco-design guide](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/cosmetics-environmental-impact/) describes.
- "Carbon neutral thanks to offsetting" becomes a quantified reduction, over a named scope and reference year, and a financial contribution presented separately.

A legal obligation is not put forward as an asset, as with "CFC-free" on an aerosol: EmpCo prohibits presenting **a legal requirement** as a distinctive feature of the product. When no rewording holds, **the claim comes out**, which is often the case for general terms on a product without a label. Claims specific to cosmetics are covered in [the audit of the claims on a cosmetics carton](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/cosmetics-packaging-claims-audit/).

## What should you do with packaging that is already printed?

A stock is sorted **claim by claim**, not product by product, with 3 questions: is the claim already prohibited in France, is it covered only by EmpCo, does its evidence exist? The tree below gives what follows for each case.

In France, the claims "biodegradable" and "environmentally friendly" have been prohibited **since 1 January 2022**, like "compostable" on a plastic that is compostable only in an industrial facility. For these claims, stock printed before the European deadline **has no grandfathered status to rely on**. For those that only EmpCo prohibits, French law has not yet been passed, but sales in a country that has transposed the directive already follow its rules.

On 30 June 2026, the European consumer protection authorities published a [common understanding on old stock](https://commission.europa.eu/document/264d8c70-2f9a-4955-8e7b-154d55a9b684_en), which is not legally binding. They expect companies to come into compliance **without delay and in good faith**, and begin their checks with online claims and advertising, which are easier to correct than packaging. For stock that is already printed, they may **decline to require the destruction** or recall of the products.

In France, unsold new non-food products **must be reused, repurposed or recycled** ([Environmental Code, Article L. 541-15-8](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000043975010)), which rules out landfilling or incinerating them, as [the ban on destroying unsold textiles](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/unsold-textiles-destruction-ban/) recalls. A sticker or an in-store notice corrects the packaging until it is reprinted, as [the article on inspections and in-store stock](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-enforcement-authorities/) sets out.

For us at Projet Celsius, the useful question before printing a claim is simple: which document, issued by whom, substantiates it on this specific product? A claim that has its document **withstands changes in the legal text**, whether French law is passed tomorrow or the Green Claims Directive returns. We recommend building the file **before print approval**, at the stage of [packaging eco-design](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/packaging-eco-design-ppwr-2030/), starting with the claims repeated across a whole range. Each document is dated so that you know when to review it, and the [cost of this evidence](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/green-claims-audit-cost/) is budgeted at that point, not after an inspection.

## Key takeaways

- An environmental claim is substantiated by a document that says the same thing as the sentence, about the same object, before publication.
- "Recycled" requires a percentage, substantiated by a supplier certificate backed by a traceability method such as EN 15343.
- "Recyclable", "compostable" and "biobased" are substantiated by criteria set by decree or by test standards, on the whole product.
- A carbon figure is substantiated by an LCA that sets out its scope, and a public comparison by an LCA reviewed by a panel.
- Packaging already printed is sorted claim by claim: claims prohibited since 2022 are corrected, without destroying the stock.

To check a sentence before building your file, start with [the 3-question test](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/greenwashing-test-3-questions/), and to find out who can review all of your materials, see [how to choose an audit provider](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-green-claims-audit/).

## Frequently asked questions

## Frequently asked questions

### Who has to substantiate an environmental claim?

The trader who publishes the claim, generally the brand or the advertiser. It may rely on its suppliers' documents (material certificate, test report), but it remains answerable for them. A court or the administration may require it to provide this evidence, and may treat the claim as inaccurate if the evidence is missing or insufficient.

### Do you have to have your environmental claims verified by a third party?

Not as a general rule: the company must hold its evidence, with no mandatory verification. EmpCo requires a third party in 2 cases: a sustainability label must rest on a certification scheme or a public authority, and an announced future performance must follow a plan verified by an independent expert. The Green Claims proposal, which would have made verification general, has been stalled since June 2025, and the Commission has included its withdrawal in its 2027 work programme.

### What should you do with stock and packaging already printed with old environmental claims?

They need to be sorted claim by claim. Claims prohibited in France since 2022, such as "biodegradable", are corrected without waiting, by sticker or reprint. For the claims covered by EmpCo, the European authorities expect compliance without delay and in good faith, starting with the website and advertising, and may decline to require the destruction of stock. In France, unsold non-food products must in any case be reused, repurposed or recycled.

### Can you still say a product is "carbon neutral"?

The EmpCo Directive prohibits claiming that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact on the climate on the basis of offsetting. In France, pending the transposition law, Article L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code already governs this claim: the advertiser must publish the product's emissions assessment over its life cycle, its reduction pathway and the offsetting arrangements.

### Is a private label enough to substantiate a claim?

Only if it rests on a certification scheme: public requirements, checks by a competent and independent third party, and withdrawal of the label in case of breach. A logo that the brand awards itself without third-party checks proves nothing, and EmpCo prohibits it. According to the Commission's FAQ, the brand may remain the owner of its label if the label is open to all companies and checked by an independent third party. For a general term such as "ecological", EmpCo admits only an official ecolabel, such as the EU Ecolabel, and France already prohibits the term on a product or packaging.

### What does a company risk if it cannot substantiate its claim?

Under French law, a misleading commercial practice is an offence punishable by 2 years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, or 5 years and €750,000 when committed online. The fine may be raised to 10% of average annual turnover or, for an environmental claim, to 80% of the spending on the campaign. In July 2025, SHEIN accepted a settlement fine of €40 million from the DGCCRF, for misleading practices on its price reductions and on its environmental claims.

## Sources

- Directive (EU) 2024/825 of 28 February 2024, [empowering consumers for the green transition](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32024L0825), Article 1 (definitions, Article 6, Annex I) and Article 4.
- Directive 2005/29/EC of 11 May 2005 on [unfair commercial practices](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32005L0029), Article 12.
- French National Consumer Council (CNC), practical guide to environmental claims, May 2023, and DGCCRF, [fact sheet on environmental claims: what to remember](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/les-fiches-pratiques/allegations-environnementales-ce-quil-faut-retenir), 29 September 2025.
- French Environmental Code, [Article L. 541-9-1](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000041555718), [Articles R. 541-227 to R. 541-230](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/section_lc/LEGITEXT000006074220/LEGISCTA000045728452/) (from Decree No. 2022-748 of 29 April 2022, renumbered in 2024), [Article L. 229-68](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000043960256) and [Article L. 541-15-8](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000043975010).
- French Consumer Code, [Article L. 121-2](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000044563114) and [Article L. 132-2](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000049532070).
- Regulation (EU) 2025/40 of 19 December 2024 on [packaging and packaging waste](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32025R0040), Articles 14 and 15.
- Regulation (EC) No 66/2010 of 25 November 2009 on the [EU Ecolabel](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:02010R0066-20171114).
- ISO, [ISO 14044: environmental management, life cycle assessment, requirements and guidelines](https://www.iso.org/fr/standard/38498.html).
- European Parliament, Legislative Observatory, [procedure 2023/0085(COD), Green Claims](https://oeil.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/en/procedure-file?reference=2023/0085%28COD%29), consulted on 11 November 2026; European Commission, [2027 work programme, COM(2026) 710, Annex III](https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/strategy-documents/commission-work-programme/commission-work-programme-2027_en), 4 November 2026.
- European Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) Network, [Common understanding on old stock situations under Directive (EU) 2024/825](https://commission.europa.eu/document/264d8c70-2f9a-4955-8e7b-154d55a9b684_en), 30 June 2026.
- Senate, [legislative file for the bill containing various provisions adapting French law to EU law](https://www.senat.fr/dossier-legislatif/pjl25-118.html), No. 118 (2025-2026), adopted at first reading on 18 February 2026.
- DGCCRF, [press release on the fight against greenwashing, inspections 2023-2024](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/dgccrf/media-document/cp-dgccrf-lutte-contre-ecoblanchiment-20251001.pdf), 1 October 2025; [press release on SHEIN's settlement fine](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/dgccrf/media-document/cp-dgccrf-SHEIN-sanctionne-amende-40millions.pdf), July 2025. The Légifrance, Senate, DGCCRF and ISO (French version) pages are in French.
