---
title: "How can you tell whether a claim is greenwashing?\nThe 3-question test"
description: "A claim is greenwashing when it is vague, broader than its evidence or unsupported. The PIF test checks this in 3 questions, using cases found by the DGCCRF."
canonical: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/greenwashing-test-3-questions/
author: "Guillaume Pakula"
datePublished: 2026-06-11
dateModified: 2026-10-17
language: en
translationOf: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/greenwashing-sans-le-savoir-methode-pif/
---

# How can you tell whether a claim is greenwashing? The 3-question test

**Author**: Guillaume Pakula
**Published**: 2026-06-11
**Updated**: 2026-10-17
**Section**: Practical guide
**Canonical URL**: https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/greenwashing-test-3-questions/
**French original**: https://projetcelsius.com/blog/greenwashing-sans-le-savoir-methode-pif/
**Source**: Projet Celsius (https://projetcelsius.com/en/), a climate strategy consultancy of engineers and PhDs based in Paris and Marseille.

> An environmental claim becomes greenwashing when it stays **vague**, when it promises **more than its evidence shows** or when that evidence is **missing at the time of publication**, whether or not the company meant it to. These 3 defects are the ones that the [guide of the French National Consumer Council](https://www.arpp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Guide-pratique-des-allegations-environnementales-du-CNC-2023.pdf) calls on companies to rule out. The PIF test (from the French Précise, Intègre, Fondée: Precise, Honest, Substantiated) puts them as 3 questions, applied to real cases found by the DGCCRF (the French consumer protection authority) and the ARPP (the French advertising self-regulatory body), before a customer, a competitor or an investigator does it for you.

## Key takeaways

- A claim is misleading as soon as it is liable to mislead consumers, **with or without intent**.
- A **precise** claim names the benefit, the part concerned and the measure.
- An **honest** claim does not suggest more than what the evidence covers.
- A **substantiated** claim has its evidence in hand before publication, not afterwards.

"Eco-responsible delivery", "green breeze block", "preserving the planet": the DGCCRF (the French consumer protection authority) found these wordings in its [2023 and 2024 investigations](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/dgccrf/media-document/cp-dgccrf-lutte-contre-ecoblanchiment-20251001.pdf), which covered **more than 3,000 establishments**. All of them suggested **a general benefit** for the environment without saying which. The French Consumer Code requires no intent to deceive: a practice is misleading as soon as it rests on a claim **liable to mislead** ([Article L. 121-2](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000044563114)).

The test above sets out the 3 questions an investigator asks when looking at a sentence.

## What makes a claim misleading?

An environmental claim is more than a word printed on packaging. The [EmpCo Directive](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32024L0825) (the EU Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition directive) treats as a claim any **text, image, symbol**, label or **brand name** that states or suggests that a product or a company has a positive, zero or reduced impact on the environment. A **leaf on a bottle** or a **range name such as "Nature"** falls within scope.

### What the Consumer Code says

In France, Article L. 121-2 treats as misleading a practice that rests on claims that are false or liable to mislead. These may concern the **essential characteristics** of a product, including its environmental impact, or the **scope of the advertiser's commitments** on environmental matters. The text judges **the effect on the consumer**, not the intent of whoever wrote the sentence.

[The EmpCo Directive](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/what-is-empco-directive/) adds a list of practices banned in all circumstances, applicable since **27 September 2026** in the countries that have transposed it. In France, the transposition bill was adopted by the Senate on 18 February 2026 and **has yet to be voted on** by the National Assembly. [Who is affected](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-who-is-affected/) and [from when it applies](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-application-dates/) are covered separately.

> **Good to know** The French Ministry of the Economy (Bercy) sums up the rule in 4 adjectives: an environmental claim is prohibited when it is false, disproportionate, unjustified and/or impossible to verify ([Bercy infos, June 2024](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/entreprises/gerer-sa-comptabilite-et-ses-demarches/entreprises-comment-valoriser-votre-action)).

### A risk that also reaches large brands

The [advertising and environment review](https://www.arpp.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Bilan-ARPP-ADEME-Publicite-et-environnement-2023-2024-1.pdf) by the ARPP (the French advertising self-regulatory body) and ADEME (the French Agency for Ecological Transition), published in October 2024, examined **1,015 advertisements** with an ecological argument: **65 did not comply** with the advertising ethics rules. They came from companies of all sizes, some of which sometimes used large consultancy agencies. The 2 main reasons correspond to the **first 2 questions** of the test, detailed below.

### Where the 3 questions of the test come from

The practical guide to environmental claims of the French National Consumer Council (CNC), reissued in 2023, asks professionals to respect **3 principles**: clarity and absence of ambiguity, proportionality of the claim, and the existence of supporting evidence. The PIF test (from the French Précise, Intègre, Fondée) takes them up in the order in which you would check a sentence.

- Precise corresponds to clarity: the sentence says which benefit, for which part of the product and to what extent, with no vague term.
- Honest corresponds to proportionality: what the customer takes away from the sentence, images included, does not go beyond what the company has done.
- Substantiated corresponds to supporting evidence: the evidence exists, is dated and can be found before publication, not after an inspection.

## Does the claim say exactly what, and about what?

A precise claim names **the benefit**, **the part concerned** and **the measure**. The Ministry puts it simply: consumers must understand immediately **what exactly the claim relates to**. A sentence that prompts a "meaning what?" fails this first question.

### Words that say nothing

Among the **abusive claims** in its 2023-2024 review, the ARPP cites "positive impact", "preserves the planet", "ecological swimming pool", "durable tableware" and "responsible and committed beauty". None says **what has been reduced**, or by how much. The DGCCRF ordered importers to remove "eco friendly" and "eco responsible" from [sunglasses](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/actualites-dgccrf/nous-sommes-tres-vigilants-sur-la-justification-des-allegations-environnementales) that contained only a share of bio-based material, with no percentage displayed.

EmpCo prohibits these [generic claims](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/banned-environmental-claims-eu/) in all circumstances (Annex I, point 4a), except where the company demonstrates **recognised environmental excellence**: the EU Ecolabel or an official Type I ecolabel (ISO 14024 standard). Outside that case, the generic word is replaced with **the fact it summed up**.

### The product, the packaging or the company?

The CNC guide points out that "eco-designed" with no further detail refers to **the product and its packaging** together. "Recyclable" must say **what is recycled** (the bottle, not the pump) and under what **collection conditions**, as for any [eco-designed packaging](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/packaging-eco-design-ppwr-2030/). A claim about the company ("committed to the climate") calls for **a file covering the whole company**, not one plant.

### Wordings already banned in France

Some sentences fail before the test even begins. Since 1 January 2022, [Article L. 541-9-1 of the French Environmental Code](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/section_lc/LEGITEXT000006074220/LEGISCTA000041554872/) has prohibited, on a product or its packaging, the wordings **"biodegradable"** and **"respectful of the environment"**, or any equivalent wording. A plastic that is compostable only in an industrial unit cannot carry the word "compostable". A "recycled" wording gives the **percentage of recycled material** incorporated, as our article on [recycled content](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/ppwr-recycled-content-verification/) points out.

For "biodegradable", the DGCCRF reminds companies that an **administrative fine** of up to **€15,000** can be imposed. [Bioplastics](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/bioplastics-market-2026-strategy-mistakes/) are the first affected, because their selling point often lies in that word.

## Does the customer take away more than what is proven?

This is the question of **proportionality**. The CNC guide asks that a claim express the advertiser's action accurately, in line with its supporting evidence. A **sentence that is exact word for word** can fail here, if **the overall impression** promises more than what has been done.

### A detail presented as the whole

EmpCo prohibits presenting a claim about the whole product or company when it concerns only one aspect or one activity (Annex I, point 4b). The DGCCRF found a furniture store announcing that the majority of its wood was FSC (Forest Stewardship Council) certified, when this applied to **only a minority of products**. A recyclable cap promoted on a bottle that is not recyclable follows the same logic.

### Colours, images and brand names

The CNC warns that illustrations of the Earth and predominantly green drawings can be misleading. The DGCCRF cites a study carried out by OpinionWay and presented by ADEME in September 2020: **nearly half of French people** see in "green", "ecological" or "biodegradable" on a pack the guarantee of a more ecological product. Its investigations also target **brand names** with an environmental connotation, which colour a whole range, in [cosmetics](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/cosmetics-packaging-claims-audit/) as elsewhere.

### Neutrality, future targets and legal obligations

3 cases recur under this question:

- Describing a product as "carbon neutral" thanks to offset credits is prohibited by EmpCo (point 4c) and regulated in France by Article L. 229-68, as our article on [carbon neutrality](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/carbon-neutral-claims-what-companies-can-say/) explains.
- A target such as "net zero in 2050" requires, according to the EmpCo Directive, a detailed plan with measurable milestones, regularly checked by an independent third-party expert, like a [Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) pathway](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/sbti-for-industrial-smes/).
- Presenting as a selling point what the law requires of all products in the category is prohibited (point 10a): the Ministry cites the "bisphenol-free" baby bottle, although bisphenol is banned in baby bottles.

The photos below apply the test to wordings found on real products. The same defect recurs across very different products.

## Does the evidence exist before publication?

The CNC guide sets the timing: professionals must have the evidence required to support their claims **from the moment the claims are used**, or be able to produce it on request. For a figure, the advertiser must be able to give **the origin of the results** and the calculation method. The Ministry asks for **scientific evidence** and **recognised methods**.

### What the DGCCRF rejects as evidence

Investigators have published several rejections, which show what evidence is not:

- Sales brochures from the supplier, presented by an importer to justify "eco friendly": the DGCCRF saw advertising in them, not scientific evidence.
- Around fifteen certificates for wooden toys described as "ecological", some unrelated to the products and others expired since 2013.
- Decarbonisation claims by a chocolate maker, when the new energy source was only at the project stage and the cocoa came via a trader.
- Partners announced as labelled by a tour operator, on a mere declaration, with no supporting document to produce.

> Evidence assembled after an inspection arrives too late for a sentence already published.

### Evidence in proportion to the sentence

The evidence follows **the scale of the claim**. A composition or **recycled-material** wording is justified by a technical data sheet, a material certificate or supplier traceability. A climate wording calls for a calculation: a [Bilan Carbone® (the French carbon accounting method) or a life cycle assessment (LCA)](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/lca-vs-carbon-footprint/) depending on whether the sentence concerns the company or the product, and [an LCA has a cost](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/lca-cost/) that needs budgeting before the campaign. A [comparison with a competitor](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/comparative-environmental-claim-less-polluting/) calls for a common method.

Labels obey the same rule. EmpCo prohibits displaying a sustainability label that is neither based on a **certification scheme** run by a third party nor established by a public authority (point 2a). Before affixing a logo, you need to know [who issues it and who checks it](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/sustainable-tourism-labels-compared/).

## What should you do with a claim that fails the test?

A "no" in the test does not condemn the sentence. Each failed question calls for **a different action**:

- After a no on Precise, the sentence is reworded: it replaces the generic word with the benefit, the part concerned and the figure.
- After a no on Honest, the promise is scaled back to the exact level of the evidence, images, colours and range name included.
- After a no on Substantiated, the claim is withdrawn while the evidence is gathered, then returns in its justified form.

The table below applies these actions to 5 sentences found by the DGCCRF or targeted by EmpCo. The corrected versions are examples, to be adapted to **the evidence each company holds**.

### Where to start

The **most-seen materials** come first: the home page, packaging and advertisements currently running. Generic wordings and "carbon neutral" claims come next, because a competitor or an investigator spots them first. For packaging already printed, the European authorities have published a [common approach on existing stock](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-enforcement-authorities/). Beyond a few dozen sentences, an [audit of environmental claims](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-green-claims-audit/) takes an inventory medium by medium.

### What a claim that stays online risks

A misleading commercial practice is punished by **2 years' imprisonment and a fine of €300,000** (Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer Code), which the Ministry puts at **€1.5 million** for a legal entity. The fine can reach **10% of average annual turnover**, or **80% of the campaign spending** when the practice rests on an environmental claim. Online, the penalties rise to **5 years and €750,000**.

In 2025, SHEIN accepted a **settlement fine of €40 million**, partly for environmental claims it could not justify, including a 25% reduction in its emissions. Most cases are settled earlier, however. Over 2023 and 2024, the DGCCRF sent **more than 500 warnings** and **more than 430 injunctions**, and the **great majority** of the professionals inspected corrected or withdrew their claims of their own accord.

> A claim is judged on what the customer understands from it.

At Projet Celsius, we find that the safest sentence is often the most modest: a figure, its scope and its date, with the evidence filed alongside. The test is done at the moment of writing, when correcting costs only a sentence. A company that cannot state anything quantified gains more by [reducing its emissions](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/how-to-reduce-company-carbon-footprint/) and measuring them than by looking for the right word. The [online tool from ADEME](https://communication-responsable.ademe.fr/antigreenwashing) complements this test for an entire campaign.

## Key takeaways

- An environmental claim is misleading as soon as it misleads consumers, whether or not the company meant it to.
- A precise claim names the benefit, the part of the product concerned and the measure, with no generic word.
- An honest claim does not suggest more than the evidence supports, images, colours and brand name included.
- A substantiated claim rests on dated evidence, assembled before publication and available to hand to an investigator.
- A sentence that fails is reworded, scaled back to the level of its evidence, or withdrawn while it is proven.

To build the evidence file, see [how to substantiate an environmental claim](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/green-claims-what-empco-bans/); for all the texts together, see our [overview of environmental communication](https://projetcelsius.com/en/blog/empco-directive-green-claims-guide/).

## Frequently asked questions

### How can you tell whether an advertisement is greenwashing?

Ask it 3 questions. Does it say precisely which benefit, for which part of the product and to what extent? Does what the customer takes away from it, images included, stay within the limits of the evidence? Does that evidence exist, dated, before the advertisement is broadcast? A "no" to any one of the 3 is enough for the advertisement to risk being judged misleading.

### Is unintentional greenwashing penalised?

Yes. Article L. 121-2 of the Consumer Code treats as misleading a practice that rests on a claim liable to mislead, without requiring intent. Most cases are settled by a warning or an injunction to correct, but the fine can reach €300,000, 10% of turnover or 80% of the campaign spending.

### Can you still write "ecological" or "sustainable"?

On its own, with no further detail, such a word is risky everywhere and is prohibited in all circumstances by the EmpCo Directive in the countries that have transposed it, unless recognised excellence such as the EU Ecolabel is shown. In France, the transposition law has not been passed as of 17 October 2026, but the DGCCRF already has these words withdrawn when nothing specifies or justifies them.

### Can you write "recyclable" on packaging?

Yes, if the wording says what is recycled and under what collection conditions. For products covered by an extended producer responsibility (EPR) scheme, Decree No. 2022-748 governs the wordings "mostly recyclable" and "fully recyclable". The second is reserved for cases where more than 95% of the collected waste becomes material again.

### Can you still say "carbon neutral"?

Based on offsetting, this claim is prohibited by the EmpCo Directive for a product. In France, pending transposition, it remains regulated by Article L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code, which requires publishing an emissions assessment, a reduction pathway and the offsets. The safe route is to announce a measured reduction.

### What evidence should you keep for an environmental claim?

Evidence in proportion to the sentence: a technical data sheet or material certificate for a composition, a Bilan Carbone® or an LCA for a climate figure, a common method for a comparison. It must be dated, linked to the product concerned, archived with the claim and available to hand to an investigator on request.

## Sources

- Consumer Code, [Article L. 121-2](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000044563114) (misleading commercial practices) and [Article L. 132-2](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000049532070) (penalties, version of 12 May 2024), Légifrance (the French government's official legal database).
- Environmental Code, [Article L. 541-9-1](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/section_lc/LEGITEXT000006074220/LEGISCTA000041554872/) (prohibited wordings, from Law No. 2020-105 of 10 February 2020), Légifrance.
- European Parliament and Council, [Directive (EU) 2024/825 of 28 February 2024](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32024L0825) (EmpCo), Article 1 (definitions, Article 6(2)(d)) and Annex I (points 2a, 4a, 4b, 4c, 10a), Article 4 (transposition and application), EUR-Lex.
- National Assembly, [file of the bill adapting French law to European Union law](https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/dossiers/DLR5L17N53140), status as of 17 October 2026.
- French National Consumer Council, [practical guide to environmental claims](https://www.arpp.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Guide-pratique-des-allegations-environnementales-du-CNC-2023.pdf), 2023 edition (PDF), Annex II and the "eco-designed" and "recyclable" sheets.
- Ministry of the Economy, ["Businesses: how to promote your environmental action while avoiding greenwashing?"](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/entreprises/gerer-sa-comptabilite-et-ses-demarches/entreprises-comment-valoriser-votre-action), Bercy infos, 4 June 2024.
- DGCCRF, ["We are very vigilant about the justification of environmental claims"](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/dgccrf/actualites-dgccrf/nous-sommes-tres-vigilants-sur-la-justification-des-allegations-environnementales), 5 September 2023.
- DGCCRF, [review of the 2023 and 2024 investigations into greenwashing](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/dgccrf/media-document/cp-dgccrf-lutte-contre-ecoblanchiment-20251001.pdf), press release of 1 October 2025 (PDF).
- DGCCRF, [penalty imposed on SHEIN](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/files/files/directions_services/dgccrf/media-document/cp-dgccrf-SHEIN-sanctionne-amende-40millions.pdf), press release of 3 July 2025 (PDF).
- ARPP and ADEME, [Advertising and environment review 2023-2024](https://www.arpp.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Bilan-ARPP-ADEME-Publicite-et-environnement-2023-2024-1.pdf), October 2024 (PDF).
- ADEME, [online anti-greenwashing tool](https://communication-responsable.ademe.fr/antigreenwashing), responsible communication website. The Légifrance pages are in French, as are the other French sources above, whose titles are translated here.
