- 1The Bilan Carbone® is a decision-making tool: it shows where to act, without penalising anyone.
- 2The calculation rests on one rule: activity data × emission factor, over 1 year.
- 3In SMEs, purchases of goods are the largest category in 54% of assessments.
- 4A first assessment starts at the Initial level, carried out alone, trained or supported.
A Bilan Carbone® (the French carbon accounting method) counts an organisation's greenhouse gas emissions over one year: its own, and those of the flows its activity depends on, from the purchase of materials to the end of life of the products it sells. Created in 2004 for ADEME (the French Agency for Ecological Transition), the method has belonged since 2011 to the Association pour la transition Bas Carbone (ABC), the French non-profit that owns it, and its methodology guide has been at version 9 since July 2024.
The key concepts of a Bilan Carbone®, around a workshop
The flows a workshop depends on, sorted into 3 scopes, and the calculation for one flow over 1 year.
The calculation for one flow: heating gas
Activity data
10,000 kWh
of gas over the year, read from the invoices
Emission factor
0.215 kgCO2e
per kWh of natural gas, ADEME's Base Empreinte
Emissions
2.15 tCO2e± 5 %, of which 1.81 t burned on site (Scope 1) and the gas upstream in Scope 3
The Bilan Carbone® makes this calculation for every flow the activity depends on, over 1 year, then adds up the tonnes.
It gives orders of magnitude, not decimals: it is a decision-making tool, to see where to act.
Sources: ABC, Bilan Carbone® methodology guide, version 9 · GHG Protocol · ADEME, Base Carbone® V23.6 (July 2025). Example quantities.
The result does not need to be accurate to the tonne: it must show the categories that carry weight. As the guide puts it, the method does not measure an organisation's responsibility for global warming, it identifies its potential for action. The 5 points that follow run from the concepts to know to the choice between doing it alone, getting trained or being supported.
1What should you know before a Bilan Carbone®?
A decision-making tool
The Bilan Carbone® is a decision-making tool. It is not meant to produce a figure exact to the decimal, nor to grade the organisation: it sorts emissions by category to show which to reduce first. The law, moreover, penalises failing to produce an assessment where one is mandatory, never a high result. An assessment is compared first with itself, from one year to the next, rather than with that of a company in another line of business, which has neither the same boundaries nor the same calculation choices.
The 6 concepts to know
6 concepts are enough to read a Bilan Carbone® and discuss it with a consultancy, a software provider or management:
- The tonne of CO2 equivalent, written tCO2e, adds up all greenhouse gases, each weighted by its effect on the climate compared with that of CO2.
- Activity data is what the organisation consumes or does: kWh on invoices, litres of diesel, kilometres, tonnes or euros of purchases.
- The emission factor converts that data into emissions: 0.215 kgCO2e per kWh of natural gas, for example, in ADEME's Base Empreinte, its public emission factor database.
- The boundaries define what goes into the assessment: entities and sites first, then the flows and categories retained, starting from what the activity depends on.
- Scopes 1, 2 and 3 sort the emissions: those from sites and vehicles, those from purchased energy, then all the others, upstream and downstream.
- The reference year is the first year measured, usually the last closed calendar or financial year, and serves as the baseline for later assessments.
Bilan Carbone®, BEGES, GHG Protocol: who sets what?
The Bilan Carbone® is a voluntary method, and a trademark of the ABC. The regulatory report, often called the BEGES (bilan d'émissions de gaz à effet de serre), France's mandatory greenhouse gas emissions report, is the obligation set by Article L. 229-25 of the French Environmental Code: it covers companies with more than 500 employees (250 in overseas France), every 4 years, and large public bodies, every 3 years. The phrase we repeat in our training courses sums up the division of roles: the law says you must report, the method says how.
2 international frameworks are authoritative. The ISO 14064-1 standard serves as the basis for third-party verification. The GHG Protocol, whose Corporate Standard dates from 2004, sorts emissions into 3 scopes, and it is the one followed by the CSRD and the major investor questionnaires. The calculation is the same everywhere, and a Bilan Carbone® can be reported in each of these formats: it meets the BEGES requirements from its Initial level. The differences are set out in our comparison of the GHG Protocol and the Bilan Carbone®, and the obligation in our BEGES guide.
Bilan Carbone®, BEGES, ISO 14064-1 and GHG Protocol compared
The same calculation everywhere: activity data × emission factor. They differ on what is mandatory and on what is published.
Sources: ABC, Bilan Carbone® guide v9; French Environmental Code, Article L. 229-25; Ministry of Ecological Transition, BEGES method v5 (2022); ISO 14064-1:2018; GHG Protocol Corporate Standard. Logos: ABC, French Republic, ISO, GHG Protocol.
The law penalises the absence of an assessment, never a high result.
2What does a Bilan Carbone® measure?
A Bilan Carbone® counts the emissions induced by the activity, direct and indirect, upstream and downstream. It therefore goes well beyond the company's boiler and cars: purchased materials, the transport of goods, employee travel and the use of the products sold are included too.
The 10 emission categories of a Bilan Carbone®, from upstream to downstream
For each category: what it counts, the data to ask for and a calculation with an ADEME factor.
Energy
What it counts
Gas, fuel oil and wood burned on the sites; electricity, heat and cooling purchased.
The data to ask for
Energy invoices and meter readings (facilities management, accounts).
A worked example
Base Carbone®: natural gas 2022, average mix, consumption, mainland France, in kWh GCV (gross calorific value) (ID 37133).
Benchmark: electricity in France in 2024, 0.0519 kgCO2e per kWh (ID 43642).
Every line is calculated the same way: activity data × emission factor = tCO2e ± uncertainty.
The assessment shows where the tonnes are, so you can decide where to act.
Sources: ABC, Bilan Carbone® methodology guide, version 9, Annex 1; ADEME, Base Carbone® V23.6 (July 2025).
The emissions the activity depends on
A simple test decides what goes in: if this flow disappeared, would the activity stay the same? If not, the flow is in the assessment, even when another company emits it. The guide takes the logic all the way downstream: a carmaker counts the fuel its cars will burn once sold, over their whole lifetime.
The Bilan Carbone® counts 7 gases that are mandatory, from CO2 to nitrogen trifluoride, and aircraft contrails by default. Avoided emissions at third parties and sequestered carbon are reported separately and are never deducted from the total: a Bilan Carbone® cannot claim carbon neutrality. A product's footprint calls for a different exercise, life cycle assessment.
The 10 categories and the BEGES
Emissions are sorted into 10 emission categories and 48 subcategories, and each emission goes into a single subcategory. The categories follow the organisation's main flows: what comes in, what happens on its sites and journeys, what becomes of its products. According to the guide, they give a clear view of the areas where action is the priority.

The guide's figure arranges the categories by flow: what comes in on the left (goods, services, capital goods), what happens on the sites in the centre (energy, other direct emissions, waste, travel), what becomes of the products on the right (use, end of life). Freight links the 3. Each emission goes into a single subcategory.
The same calculation can be reported in the other formats, thanks to the guide's correspondence tables. Categories 3 to 6 of the BEGES cover what the GHG Protocol calls Scope 3:
- Energy burned on site and other direct emissions, such as refrigerant leaks, form category 1 of the BEGES and Scope 1.
- Electricity, heat and cooling bought from a network form category 2 of the BEGES and Scope 2 of the GHG Protocol.
- Freight and travel go into category 3 of the BEGES, transport, when the organisation does not operate the vehicles itself.
- Purchases of goods and services, capital goods and waste go into category 4 of the BEGES, purchased products.
- Use and end of life of the products sold go into category 5, except use in dependence, which neither the BEGES nor the GHG Protocol provides for.
What the categories weigh in an SME
In a real assessment, the categories are far from carrying the same weight. Our analysis of the assessments of 1,938 SMEs published on the ADEME platform under the Diag Décarbon'Action (a Bpifrance-subsidised carbon footprint programme for companies established in France) shows this:
- Purchases of goods are the largest category in 54% of assessments, and in 3 out of 4 in industry and construction.
- Scopes 1 and 2, meaning fuels, vehicle fuel and electricity, account for 3.7% of the assessment at the median.
- Transport and logistics are the exception: lorry diesel brings Scopes 1 and 2 to 46.6% at the median.
- In consulting and digital services, purchases of services come first, at 22% and 29% of the assessment at the median.
An assessment that stopped at the boiler and the vehicles would therefore miss what matters most in most SMEs. The breakdown by sector and company size is in our analysis of the assessments of 1,938 SMEs.
3How are emissions calculated?
All of carbon accounting comes down to a single rule, which the guide writes as: emissions from a source = activity data x emission factor = result ± uncertainty. The units must cancel out: kWh with a factor per kWh, tonnes with a factor per tonne. An invoice in MWh read as kWh is enough to skew the result by a factor of 1,000.

Activity data
Activity data is what the organisation consumes or does: kWh on invoices, litres of diesel, kilometres travelled, tonnes purchased, euros from the accounting export. The best data is the closest to the emission. For a furniture maker's wood, tonnes by species and origin are better than a number of chairs multiplied by their weight, which is better than an amount in euros.
The emission factor
In France, the method's reference database is ADEME's Base Empreinte, free of charge, created by merging the Base Carbone® and the Base Impact®. Most of its factors carry an uncertainty, from 5% for natural gas to 80% for spend-based emission factors. Gas has 2 factors there, depending on the unit: 0.215 kgCO2e per kWh GCV (gross calorific value), the unit used on invoices, and 0.239 per kWh NCV (net calorific value).
The choice of factor sometimes changes everything. A 1,000 km short-haul flight weighs 225 kgCO2e per passenger, contrails included; the same journey by TGV, the French high-speed train, 2.9 kgCO2e, more than 70 times less. Train factors, and what they count, are detailed in our article on the TGV.
Purchases counted in euros
When the quantity is missing, the method accepts a spend-based emission factor: kgCO2e per thousand euros spent, by broad purchase family. ADEME publishes 56 of them, established for 2022, and all carry 80% uncertainty. Their advantage is real: the accounting export is enough to estimate all purchases in one go, including digital services.
Emissions per €1,000 excl. VAT spent, by type of purchase
Light band: 80% uncertainty, from 0.2 to 1.8 times the value. French electricity carries 10%, natural gas 5%.
For the same spend, the gap exceeds 40 times, and every ratio carries 80% uncertainty. Euros are for spotting the large purchases.
Source: ADEME, Base Carbone® V23.6, 13 of the 56 spend-based factors for 2022, kgCO2e per €1,000 excl. VAT. Calculation: Projet Celsius.
For the same spend, what is bought makes emissions vary by more than 40 times, from 29 kgCO2e per €1,000 of real estate services to 1,267 kgCO2e for agricultural products. Euros are therefore for finding the large categories. They do not measure progress: paying less for the same product would lower emissions on paper without changing anything in reality. Once identified, the 2 or 3 purchases that carry weight are switched to quantities, with the help of supplier data.
Uncertainty, shown and accepted
Version 9 requires uncertainty to be estimated category by category and shown on the emissions profile. The guide's FAQ gives the reason: overall uncertainty is not enough to move properly into action, whereas the detail by category makes it possible to prioritise the most impactful actions. An action plan needs orders of magnitude, not decimals: an assessment accurate to within 30% is enough to see that one category weighs 5 times more than another. The guide also requires a detailed analysis of the 3 largest categories in the assessment.
4How do you carry out a Bilan Carbone®, step by step?
The Bilan Carbone® process has 7 steps, and the calculation is only one of them: the first 2 take place before any data collection. Only the last one, the evaluation, is optional.
The 7 steps of the Bilan Carbone® 2025 method
For each step, what you do and what you get.
Step 4 of 7, required
Account for emissions
The 4 framing decisions
4 decisions are made before asking for a single invoice:
- Organisational boundaries: which entities, sites and buildings are included in the assessment, including those the organisation only rents.
- Reference year: a full financial period, usually the past calendar or financial year, which will serve as the baseline for later assessments.
- Operational boundaries: which flows and categories are included in the assessment, starting from what the activity depends on.
- Target level, Initial, Standard or Advanced, which sets the precision expected from data collection and the ambition of the transition plan.
Each category has its data holder: energy invoices with facilities management, the accounting export with the accounts department, the commuting survey with human resources. A designated contact in each department speeds up collection. In the accounting export, you should identify from the outset the 2 or 3 purchase families that carry weight, so as to ask for quantities.
The transition plan, at the centre
The transition plan is step 5, and it is part of the Bilan Carbone®: reduction targets, detailed and costed actions, a trajectory and tracking indicators. The ABC says so in its FAQ: the Bilan Carbone® goes beyond accounting for emissions and guides the organisation towards building its transition plan. The reduction levers, category by category, are in our guide to reducing your emissions.
A Bilan Carbone® without a transition plan does not comply with the method, even if the calculation is right.
Initial, Standard or Advanced
The level is chosen at the framing stage. The Initial level suits a first assessment, a small organisation, a regulatory BEGES or a Diag Décarbon'Action. The Standard level corresponds to the Bilan Carbone® as it has always been done. The Advanced level covers, according to the guide, most of ESRS E1, the CSRD climate standard. Its correspondence table with the CSRD dates from October 2024, before the revision of the standards presented in the revised ESRS.
Bilan Carbone® method levels, from Initial to Advanced
For each maturity level, who it is for and what the method requires.
Initial
A first Bilan Carbone®
Standard
Action on all emissions
Advanced
An assessment that drives strategy
For a first assessment, we recommend the Initial level. The organisation may also aim directly for the level that matches its objectives, but it must progress with each renewal, even without changing level. How often to renew is covered in our article on how often to carry out an assessment.
How long to allow
In our experience, data collection takes 1 to 6 months, in a process of 4 to 9 months in total, and the calculation is the quick part. The gap depends mainly on the state of the data: a single-site SME whose accounts classify purchases well moves faster than a multi-site organisation. The most common pitfalls of a first assessment are gathered in our answers to frequently asked questions.
5How to start: alone, trained or supported?
3 routes lead to a first assessment, and they can be combined:
Doing a Bilan Carbone® alone, trained or supported
The 3 routes all lead to an assessment; they differ in the team's time and in the outside view.
Public benchmarks, no official fee schedule. Sources: Mission Transition Écologique; ABC, training prices; Bpifrance, Diag Décarbon'Action (2026).
Alone, with the free tools
A company may measure its emissions without a provider and without training. ADEME's Base Empreinte provides the emission factors free of charge, and the ministry's method describes the regulatory report. The resulting assessment is valid, but it does not carry the Bilan Carbone® name, which requires training. Our guide to doing your own assessment details these tools and what this choice costs in time.
Trained, with the ABC course
According to the ABC, training is required to apply the Bilan Carbone® method. 5 bodies are authorised to deliver it, at the same public price of €1,300 excl. VAT per module, with 7 to 14 hours online followed by 1 day with a trainer. The Initiation module is enough to carry out your own organisation's assessment. The up-to-date tools, the spreadsheet and the Bilan Carbone+ platform, also require membership of the ABC.

The ABC presents BC+ as the successor to the Bilan Carbone® spreadsheet, taking over its functions and adding new features. It is intended for all users, specialists or not, who will be able to move faster than with a spreadsheet. This presentation comes from the ABC, which publishes the tool, and does not compare it with software from other publishers that it audits.
The training is funded like any professional training: by the employer, by the sector's OPCO (the body that funds training for a business sector) for companies with fewer than 50 employees, and by the CPF (the French personal training account) for the certifying course only, with entitlements capped at €1,500. The choice of training body and funding is detailed in our guide to Bilan Carbone® training (in French). We help run Bilan Carbone® training courses with IFC.D, one of these bodies.
Supported, by a consultancy
A consultancy runs the framing, helps with data collection, calculates, checks and reports, while the team provides the data. For an SME, Mission Transition Écologique, the French government's support service for businesses, puts the cost at around €10,000 for a full assessment with a consultancy. An SME eligible for the Diag Décarbon'Action pays only €6,000 excl. VAT, after a 40% subsidy. Benchmarks for comparing 2 quotes are in our article on the price of a Bilan Carbone®, and those for choosing a provider in our guide to choosing a consultancy.
The name guarantees a method applied by trained people, with up-to-date tools. A Bilan Carbone® is not certified: it may be evaluated, as the 7th step and on a voluntary basis, by an authorised independent team, under the scheme set up by the ABC with AFNOR Certification and the Ordre des experts-comptables, the French institute of chartered accountants. Third-party verification of an assessment outside this scheme is a different exercise.
5 checks before trusting a result
A calculation file should be reviewed with 5 questions, whether it comes from a consultancy, a software tool or an AI:
- Do the data and its factor share the same unit, kWh with a factor per kWh, tonnes with a factor per tonne?
- Does each factor have a source, a year and a geographical area written next to the calculation, and does that factor in fact appear in that source?
- Are the boundaries written down and applied in the same way throughout, including rented sites and hired vehicles?
- Does the result remain plausible once related to a benchmark, per employee, per product sold or per million euros of turnover?
- Is nothing counted 2 times, such as energy present both in the invoices and in the accounting export, and is nothing subtracted from the total?

6What do we recommend for a first Bilan Carbone®?
For us at Projet Celsius, a first Bilan Carbone® is for deciding rather than counting. We advise aiming for the Initial level, identifying in the accounting export the 2 or 3 purchase families that carry weight, then measuring them in tonnes rather than in euros. We also advise training the person who will steer data collection, even when a consultancy carries out the assessment: that person will update it the following year.
We carry out Bilan Carbone® assessments, we support teams that run them themselves and, as a first step, we can simply explain the process using the organisation's data. Our Bilan Carbone® support describes this work, and a first conversation is enough to establish the starting point.
7Key takeaways
- The Bilan Carbone® is a decision-making tool: it shows where to act, without grading or penalising.
- It counts the emissions the activity depends on over 1 year, sorted into 10 categories and into Scopes 1, 2 and 3.
- Each line multiplies activity data by an emission factor, with its uncertainty.
- In the assessments of 1,938 SMEs, purchases of goods are the largest category in 54% of cases, and Scopes 1 and 2 account for 3.7% at the median.
- A first assessment is carried out at the Initial level, alone, trained or supported, in 4 to 9 months in our experience.
To calculate the heaviest category for most organisations, see the Scope 3 guide, and to put a result in context, carbon orders of magnitude.
- ABC, Bilan Carbone® methodology guide, version 9 (CC BY-SA 4.0 licence): foreword, change history, objectives and principles, steps, maturity levels, emissions accounted for, quantification, emission factors, emissions profile and correspondence tables, Annex 1, the 10 categories, evaluation, FAQ, accessed 2 November 2026. The guide and the ABC pages are in French.
- ABC: the Bilan Carbone® 2025 method, Bilan Carbone® training, Bilan Carbone+, member charter (2026), accessed 2 November 2026.
- French Environmental Code: Article L. 229-25, version in force since 3 May 2025. Ministry of Ecological Transition: method for carrying out greenhouse gas emissions reports, version 5, July 2022. The Légifrance pages are in French.
- ADEME: Base Empreinte; Base Carbone®, open dataset V23.6, updated on 3 July 2025: factors for natural gas 2022, electricity 2024, short- and medium-haul flights 2023, the TGV 2022, and 56 spend-based emission factors for 2022, including the one for wood, read on 2 November 2026.
- ADEME: greenhouse gas emissions report dataset, data as of 2 November 2026, Licence Ouverte 2.0: assessments published with Diag Décarbon'Action support, 1,938 companies, analysis by Projet Celsius.
- Mission Transition Écologique: carrying out a greenhouse gas emissions report, accessed 2 November 2026. Bpifrance: Diag Décarbon'Action, accessed 2 November 2026.
- GHG Protocol: Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard, WRI and WBCSD, 2004. ISO 14064-1:2018, International Organization for Standardization.
- Cover photo: the SAIREM assembly workshop in Neyron (Ain), in October 2011, Achkostik, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.




