- 15 frameworks overlap in 2026: France's Climate and Resilience Act, DGCCRF, EmpCo, Green Claims and AMF.
- 2EmpCo sets an application date of 27 September 2026, but France has not transposed it.
- 3The French framework already imposes penalties: the carbon neutrality decree since 2023 and active DGCCRF enforcement.
- 4The strength of the evidence remains the constant that holds as the legal texts change.
In 2026, environmental communications are governed by 5 overlapping frameworks that regulate what a brand may say about the environment: France's Climate and Resilience Act, the French Consumer Code, Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition (EmpCo), the Green Claims proposal and the financial framework. None replaces the others, and each has its own basis for penalties. Marketing and CSR (corporate social responsibility) teams nevertheless face the same 5 questions: the map below addresses each in turn and links to its detailed guide.
Contents of the EmpCo and Green Claims guides
The 5 questions people ask about the anti-greenwashing directive, each with its short answer and the guide that covers it in depth.
The European anti-greenwashing directive (EU 2024/825). It adds 12 practices to the blacklist, 4 of which target environmental claims: they are banned in all circumstances.
Yes, as soon as you mention the environment to consumers, through a word, a visual or a green leaf, whatever your size.
Applicable since 27 September 2026 in the European Union. In France, the transposition law is still awaiting the National Assembly, but French law already imposes penalties.
The precise, proven fact: "eco-friendly" on its own becomes "packaging made from 80% recycled cardboard".
Precise, Honest, Substantiated: a 3-question screening grid to run before every publication.
Sources: this article, Directive (EU) 2024/825, Projet Celsius series guides.
Waiting for a "final version" of the framework before acting is a mistake: the framework will keep evolving, and penalties are already being imposed under French legislation in force. The safest approach is to work on the one element common to every framework, the scientific soundness of each environmental claim, also known as a green claim.
1The 5 legal frameworks governing your claims
EmpCo, the European anti-greenwashing directive, has been adopted, with an EU application date of 27 September 2026 (France has yet to transpose it). It is part of a wider framework: focusing on it alone overlooks most of the risk, which is already active in France.
Texts governing environmental communications in France
5 texts add up without replacing one another, each with its own route to penalties. Hover over or tap an instrument for details.
12 new prohibited practices in Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC, including 4 on environmental claims and labels. Coordinated EU penalty ceiling: at least 4% of turnover (Directive 2019/2161), with France keeping 10%. Reverses the burden of proof.
None of these texts replaces the others: each creates a separate basis for penalties. To understand what applies to you, you need to consider all 5 together. Here they are, from the oldest to the most recent.
Climate and Resilience Act and carbon neutrality decree (France, since 2023)
Article 12 of Law No. 2021-1104 of 22 August 2021, as detailed in Decree No. 2022-539 of 13 April 2022, regulates carbon neutral claims and equivalent wording. To use them in advertising, the advertiser must publish a report setting out the product or service's life cycle carbon footprint, its reduction pathway and the arrangements for offsetting residual emissions. The penalty is a fine of up to €100,000 for a legal entity, which may be increased to the full expenditure on the campaign. The text has applied since 1 January 2023.
Consumer Code and DGCCRF (France, already applicable)
Articles L. 121-2 onwards of the French Consumer Code define a misleading commercial practice as any claim likely to mislead the average consumer. This very broad definition covers almost all green claims lacking evidence. In its greenwashing investigations, the DGCCRF (the French consumer protection authority) inspected more than 3,000 establishments in 2023 and 2024, and found serious breaches at more than 15%. The penalty is up to 10% of turnover.

EmpCo / ECGT (EU 2024/825, application on 27 September 2026)
The Empowering Consumers Directive (EU 2024/825), also known as ECGT, was adopted on 28 February 2024. It adds 12 new entries to the blacklist in Directive 2005/29/EC, including 4 directly targeting environmental claims, as well as the presentation of a legal requirement as an advantage. These practices are now prohibited per se, without any need to prove harm. The EU-wide coordinated penalty ceiling (Omnibus Directive 2019/2161) is at least 4% of turnover, with France retaining its 10% ceiling. Our guide to what EmpCo is explains these practices in detail.
Green Claims (EU, set to be withdrawn)
Proposed in March 2023, it would have required third-party verification before publication. On 20 June 2025, the Commission announced its intention to withdraw it, and the trilogue scheduled for 23 June was cancelled. The Council never adopted a negotiating mandate. The Commission's 2027 work programme, published on 4 November 2026, includes it in Annex III among the proposals the Commission intends to withdraw within 6 months. The withdrawal is not yet formal as at 11 November 2026, according to the procedure file.
The financial framework: AMF, SFDR, CSRD
In finance, greenwashing falls under other authorities. The AMF (France's financial markets regulator) has tightened its guidance on Article 8 and 9 funds under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and the French socially responsible investment (ISR) label. Reports under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) published since 2025 are scrutinised for Net Zero commitments without supporting documentation and partial scope 3 assessments presented as complete. AMF penalties may reach €100 million, ten times the benefit derived, or 15% of total annual turnover (AMF, in French).
All 5 share the same principle: prevent consumers from being misled and shift the burden onto evidence. With EmpCo, a vague claim ceases to be a grey area and becomes a practice prohibited in all circumstances.
2Consumer-facing environmental claims are in scope regardless of size
The answer comes down to 2 cumulative criteria, and neither depends on your size: you address consumers (B2C), and your message concerns the environment. If these 2 criteria are met, you are in scope, whether you are a small or medium-sized enterprise (SME) with 8 employees or a listed group. This is a clear difference from the CSRD, which filters by headcount and turnover thresholds.
What is your company's profile?
The 5 instruments do not apply with the same intensity depending on your profile. Expand your case to see the main exposure, the key indicator and the priority action.
And a message "concerning the environment" goes further than words alone. A simple green leaf on a bottle, entirely green packaging or a range named "Nature": the visual code stands in for a claim, and is often what an inspector examines first. An implicit promise is regulated in the same way as a written one, so a green leaf is tested like a word, using the PIF method (Précise, Intègre, Fondée: precise, honest and substantiated).

The 4 typical profiles
The 5 frameworks carry different weight depending on your situation. 4 profiles cover most cases across B2C, business-to-business (B2B), finance, SMEs and micro-businesses, each with its main exposure and immediate action priority. The map above identifies your profile at a glance.
The most misunderstood case is B2B. A purely B2B supplier does not escape fines, because Article L. 121-5 of the French Consumer Code also applies misleading commercial practice rules between businesses. Nor does it escape the demand for evidence, which reaches it through 3 channels. First, its clients subject to the CSRD require its scope 3 data. Second, the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD, EU 2024/1760) will apply from 26 July 2029 to groups with more than 5,000 employees and €1.5 billion in turnover. These groups will be able to question their suppliers when the information is not available otherwise. Finally, public procurement bodies and private-sector buyers alike reject incomplete submissions.
For a B2B supplier, the practical question is therefore what its B2C clients require: they are not exempt and pass their evidence requirements down to their suppliers. Suppliers that have not established their evidence base by the end of 2026 risk losing contracts to those that have.
DGCCRF greenwashing investigations have targeted textiles, where French environmental labelling for textiles already provides some of the expected evidence, as well as cosmetics (see cosmetics eco-design), furniture and food products. The sector-by-sector assessment examines borderline cases.
3French penalties apply while EmpCo transposition is pending
The timetable has 3 dates, and the risk lies between the last 2 dates. 28 February 2024: the directive was adopted. 27 March 2026: the missed deadline for transposition into French law; the Commission sent France a letter of formal notice, along with 19 other states, on 28 May 2026. 27 September 2026: the application date set by the directive. In France, application awaits the transposing legislation, adopted by the Senate on 18 February 2026 and pending in the National Assembly.
From adoption to application
The Directive allowed 6 months between the transposition deadline and the application date. By 27 September 2026, France had still not transposed it.
Adoption of Directive (EU) 2024/825, published in the Official Journal of the European Union on 6 March 2024.
Deadline for transposition in all 27 Member States. France has not transposed it: the Commission issued a letter of formal notice on 28 May 2026.
EmpCo has applied since this date in countries that have transposed it. In France, the new prohibitions await the transposition law.
Pending the French transposing legislation, a company is already at risk of being penalised. The carbon neutrality decree has applied since 1 January 2023, the AGEC law (France's Anti-Waste and Circular Economy Act) already prohibits certain terms ("biodegradable", "environmentally friendly") and misleading commercial practices have long been punishable. In July 2025, more than a year before EmpCo's application date, the DGCCRF, for example, imposed a €40 million fine on SHEIN, partly for an unsubstantiated environmental claim.

Directive or regulation: why there is a 2-year gap
The gap between adoption (2024) and application (2026) reflects the nature of the text: EmpCo is a directive. A European regulation applies as written in every country, while a directive sets an objective that each state must incorporate into national law within a specified period, a process called transposition. This transposition period explains why the timetable spans 2 years.
France's late transposition offers no protection, for 2 reasons. First, national legislation already penalises most of the practices at issue. Second, a judge hearing a dispute interprets French law in the light of the directive (consistent interpretation), and a competitor or non-profit organisation may rely on it. Until it is transposed, however, the directive does not by itself create a new prohibition between a business and its customers. But a claim that it prohibits is already vulnerable under current law.
In practice, the European date of 27 September 2026 has passed, and the French transposing legislation remains pending in the National Assembly. Rewording claims, gathering evidence and obtaining validation often take 6 to 9 months, so a company that has not yet started is better off doing so without waiting for the vote. The full timetable and what to prepare sets out each scenario.
4Precise, substantiated claims remain possible
EmpCo targets vague, unverifiable claims; precise, substantiated communications remain possible. The rule to remember: the evidence must be as broad as the claim. A Bilan Carbone® (the French carbon accounting method) is sufficient for a climate claim, and a multi-criteria life cycle assessment (LCA) for a broad, quantified claim. The word "ecological" used on its own requires an officially recognised ecolabel, which no LCA can replace.
Verdict on 12 common environmental claims
Tap a row to see the proof required and the text that applies.
- Permitted
Proof required: Material traceability: supplier certificates kept on file, rate verifiable for the batch.
ISO 14021 (self-declared claims)
- Permitted
Proof required: Comparable quantified measurement: 2 carbon footprint assessments with the same boundary and method, gap documented.
Art. L121-2 French Consumer Code (accuracy)
- Conditional
Proof required: Recyclability in practice within the French recycling scheme (sorting instructions), not just in theory in a laboratory.
ISO 14021; CNC-ADEME guide 2023
- Conditional
Proof required: Bilan Carbone® or a quantified product footprint + an explicit comparison benchmark.
L121-2; Directive 2024/825
- Strictly regulated
Proof required: BEGES + reduction pathway + offsetting arrangements, all published (already required in advertising since 2023). It has been banned by EmpCo since 27 September 2026 where it relies on offsetting.
Decree 2022-539; Directive 2024/825
- Conditional
Proof required: Comparison using the same method, data and boundary, with the benchmark cited. A comparison that cannot be verified is a misleading practice.
L121-2; Directive 2024/825
- Conditional
Proof required: Detailed action plan, dated milestones, monitoring that a third party can verify. Without a plan, a future commitment is misleading within the meaning of EmpCo, which has applied since 27 September 2026.
Directive 2024/825
- Conditional
Proof required: Generic claim: you must specify the dimension (lifespan? material? repairability?) and prove it.
Directive 2024/825
- Almost banned
Proof required: Generic environmental claim: banned by EmpCo since 27 September 2026 unless backed by recognised environmental performance (EU Ecolabel or an equivalent official ecolabel). In France, the ban will take effect with the transposition law.
Directive 2024/825; CNC-ADEME guide
- Banned (France)
Proof required: Term banned from products and packaging by the AGEC law, regardless of the proof held.
AGEC law, Art. 13
- Banned (France)
Proof required: Same AGEC ban: the wording is banned from products and packaging in France.
AGEC law, Art. 13
- Banned since Sept. 2026
Proof required: Sustainability labels not based on a recognised certification scheme are banned by the EmpCo directive.
Directive 2024/825
Sources: Directive (EU) 2024/825; AGEC law, Art. 13; Decree 2022-539; ISO 14021; CNC-ADEME practical guide 2023.
Start by classifying the claim, as the evidence required varies. A factual claim ("30% recycled material") is substantiated by a certificate or an ISO 14021 self-declaration. A comparative claim ("40% lower emissions") requires a baseline, a period and a scope. A global claim ("ecological", "sustainable") carries the greatest risk: EmpCo prohibits its use on its own, unless supported by a recognised public label.
The 4 levels of proof for a claim
The broader the claim, the higher up the scale you need to go. Tap a level to see a concrete example of what passes and what does not.
4 formulations recur in almost every communication channel. For each, here is the version that no longer meets the rules and the one that does:
- "Ecological" on its own becomes "packaging made from 80% recycled cardboard", with the rate certified by the supplier. The mandatory Triman sorting symbol must not be presented as an advantage.
- "Low carbon" becomes "1.2 kgCO2e per unit, measured by LCA under ISO 14040, from cradle to factory gate".
- "Natural" becomes "92% natural origin under ISO 16128", with the line-by-line calculation retained.
- "Carbon neutral" or "offset" on a product will become unusable once EmpCo is transposed. In France, as at 31 October 2026, it remains permitted in advertising, provided it comes with the emissions assessment, the reduction pathway and the offsetting details required by Article L. 229-68 of the French Environmental Code. The better course is to state the actual reduction ("-15% vs 2022 on scope 1+2") and show the carbon contribution separately.
The general rule is to replace the adjective with the quantified fact. The complete method for substantiating a claim sets out the 4 steps. The PIF method, standing for Précise, Intègre, Fondée (precise, honest and substantiated), provides a 3-question screening framework to use before every publication.
5Evidence built on recognised methods holds up as the legal texts change
Everything above may change. The withdrawal of Green Claims, announced in June 2025, appears in the Commission's 2027 work programme but is not yet formal. Transposition is delayed, and delegated acts will arrive by 2030. A strategy based on the legal position at a single point in time will therefore need revisiting at each stage.
Whatever text applies when an inspection takes place, authorities, B2B buyers and judges examine the scientific substantiation of the claim. We therefore advise investing in evidence first, as it will remain useful whatever happens to the texts under discussion.
The 5 reference methods
5 methodological frameworks hold up whatever the final shape of the legal framework: multi-criteria LCA (ISO 14040/14044) for products; Bilan Carbone® scopes 1-2-3 for the company; the European Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) for product comparisons, with its French derivative Ecobalyse used for textile environmental labelling; the ISO 14020 standards for selecting the right claim type; and the ADEME-CNC environmental claims guide as the reference guide for DGCCRF inspections. ADEME is the French Agency for Ecological Transition and CNC the French National Consumer Council. The summary below specifies the scope and use of each method.
Methods to substantiate an environmental claim
Expand a row to see how each method holds up under an inspection.
Choosing between the 3 claim types (ISO 14020)
The ISO 14020 family classifies claims into 3 types according to how the claim is evidenced: Type I (a third-party verified label, such as the EU Ecolabel), Type II (a documented self-declaration, under ISO 14021) and Type III (a quantified, verified declaration, such as an Environmental Product Declaration, or EPD). The type determines the evidence to gather. For most marketing claims, teams need to know how to build a properly substantiated Type II claim internally.
3 ISO 14020 claim types
The ISO 14020 family organises environmental claims into 3 types, each suited to a different use. The type you choose determines the evidence you need to gather.
Multi-criteria, based on life cycle assessment (LCA), with regular audits by an independent accredited certification body.
Self-declaration with no third-party certification. Scientific justification and verifiable documentation are required.
Quantified, multi-criteria environmental product declaration (EPD) drawn from a third-party verified LCA. Standardised sector format.
Courts are already addressing this: on 23 October 2025, the Paris Judicial Court found TotalEnergies liable for misleading commercial practices because of its claims of carbon neutrality by 2050. At Projet Celsius, we see EmpCo as a clarification: by prohibiting neutrality through offsetting and requiring evidence matching the depth of the claim, it restores measurement to a central role. That is the purpose of our support on claims and EmpCo: ensure published messages, the scope of their claims and the supporting evidence are consistent.
6Key takeaways
- 5 frameworks overlap in 2026: France's Climate and Resilience Act and carbon neutrality decree, the French Consumer Code (DGCCRF), EmpCo (EU 2024/825), Green Claims (withdrawal planned by the Commission) and the AMF/SFDR/CSRD financial framework. None replaces the others.
- EmpCo sets an application date of 27 September 2026, with no size threshold, but France has not yet transposed it. The French framework already imposes penalties: the carbon neutrality decree has applied since 2023, and SHEIN received a €40 million fine in July 2025.
- You are affected as soon as you communicate about the environment to consumers, through a word, a visual or a green leaf. B2B companies face both fines, as misleading commercial practice rules also apply between businesses, and demands for evidence from their clients.
- 4 formulations need priority review: "ecological" must be made specific, "low carbon" quantified, "natural" backed by a standard and "offset" can no longer be used.
- Across the different texts, the strength of the evidence remains decisive: ask whether your claims would withstand an inspection tomorrow.
Which guide to read next depends on your question: what EmpCo prohibits, whether you are affected, when the rules apply, how to substantiate a claim or test a phrase in 1 minute.




